Category Archives: Crime

Another sexual misconduct case against Guv: Cops submit report to Nabanna

MP, 14 May 2024, Kolkata: Kolkata Police has reportedly sent a report to the Nabanna after conducting an enquiry on the allegations of sexual harassment of an Odishi dancer by the West Bengal Governor C V Ananda Bose. 

Sources said a few months ago a woman who is a professional dancer lodged a complaint against Bose alleging that last year she was sexually harassed by the Bengal Governor in Delhi. 
The woman reportedly claimed that last year she met the Governor who took her to Delhi to perform in a programme. A relative of Bose from Bengaluru had booked a room in a five-star hotel in Delhi for her. 
The complaint alleged that Bose sexually harassed her inside the hotel room. As no case can be registered against the Governor, Kolkata Police has started an enquiry into the matter which was reportedly led by a Deputy Commissioner ranked officer. 
After the enquiry was over, Kolkata Police submitted the report at the Nabanna in a sealed envelope. Kolkata Police presently is also conducting an enquiry based on a complaint of molestation against Bose which was filed by a contractual staff of the Raj Bhavan. 
https://www.millenniumpost.in/bengal/another-sexual-misconduct-case-against-guv-cops-submit-report-to-nabanna-563777

Illegal liquor, contraband seized; three held

EOI, Siliguri: The Excise Department seized a significant quantity of illegal liquor from a pickup van loaded with vegetables, leading to the arrest of one individual, identified as Dharmendra Kumar, a resident of Bihar. 

On Monday night, acting on a tip-off, officials of the Excise Department raided the Champasari area in Siliguri and recovered 138 cartons of foreign liquor hidden under sacks of vegetables. 
The estimated value of the liquor was Rs 31,05,000. The liquor was brought from Sikkim to be smuggled to Bihar. Meanwhile, Kharibari Police apprehended two individuals with 52 grams of brown sugar and 19 bottles of illegal cough syrup from the Panitanki overbridge in Kharibari on Monday night. 
The accused have been identified as Lalita Barman, a resident of Goursing Jote, and Bal Bahadur Tamang, a resident of Sikkim. Police sources revealed that the accused had traveled from Sikkim to Panitanki. All the suspects were produced at Siliguri Court on Tuesday

https://www.millenniumpost.in/bengal/illegal-liquor-contraband-seized-three-held-563821

Calcutta HC adjourns till Friday hear-ing of Sandeshkhali BJP leader’s peti-tion over ‘sting video’

PTI, Kolkata, May 14, 2024 : The Calcutta High Court on Tuesday adjourned till Friday the hearing of a petition by BJP’s Sandeshkhali leader Gangadhar Koyal, seeking transfer of probe to CBI into an alleged sting video over accusations of sexual atrocities in the riverine area, on a prayer by the state.

    
Advocate General Kishore Dutta, appearing for the West Bengal government, prayed for adjournment of the hearing of the matter.
    
He stated before Justice Jay Sengupta that an application has been filed by a woman before the Supreme Court, seeking inclusion as an intervenor in a plea by the state challenging a high court order, which directed CBI investigation into allegations of sexual atrocities and land-grabbing in Sandeshkhali, and as such this matter before the court be granted a short adjournment.
    
Granting the prayer, Justice Sengupta directed that Koyal’s petition seeking transfer of investigation into the alleged sting video related to allegations of sexual atrocities in Sandeshkhali be taken up for hearing again on Friday.
    
The ruling Trinamool Congress in West Bengal had recently shared a video of an alleged sting operation featuring Koyal.
    
In the purported video, the veracity of which could not be confirmed by PTI, a man resembling Koyal was seen claiming that allegations of sexual abuse in Sandeshkhali were “staged”.
    
The BJP leader had claimed in his petition that technology-aided videos mimicking his voice were being circulated in a bid to defame him.
    
Claiming that such purported videos were creating tension in Sandeshkhali and that he was apprehending a threat to his safety, Koyal also sought an order by the court for granting central force security to him.
    
The petitioner also stated that he has already met CBI officials over the alleged use of his fake voice.
    
The CBI is probing alleged sexual atrocities and land-grabbing cases in Sandeshkhali in North 24 Parganas on an earlier order of the Calcutta High Court.
    
The West Bengal government has moved an appeal before the Supreme Court, challenging the high court order.
   
The apex court posted the state’s plea for hearing in July, and made it clear that pendency of its petition will not be used as a ground for any purpose.

New video claims over 70 women received money to take part in Sandeshkhali protest

In the video, lasting over 45 minutes, a man resembling Sandeshkhali mandal president Gangadhar Kayal told this to the questioner

PTI, Calcutta, 12.05.24 : 

In a purported video that surfaced from Sandeshkhali, a local BJP leader was heard saying that over 70 women had received Rs 2,000 each for taking part in protests against local TMC satrap Shahjahan Sheikh and his aides who were accused of sexual assault and land grab.

In the video, lasting over 45 minutes, a man resembling Sandeshkhali mandal president Gangadhar Kayal told this to the questioner. It was Kayal who had earlier said in another purported clip, the first in a series in the past week, that the rape allegations were “staged”.

PTI did not independently verify the authenticity of the videos.

In the latest tape that surfaced on Saturday night, Kayal was heard saying that 70 women got Rs 2,000 each for taking part in protests against Sheikh who was arrested and later suspended by the police.

“We will need Rs 2.5 lakh in cash for 50 booths where 30 per cent of protesters would be women. We have to keep the SC, ST and OBC people here in good humour by paying them satisfactorily. In any situation, women will form the front row confronting the police,” he said in the video.

Kayal could not be contacted, but the BJP has dubbed the videos as fake.

TMC spokesperson Riju Dutta said,”The truth of the BJP’s fake narrative on Sandeshkhali is tumbling out of the closet.” Multiple purported videos of Sandeshkhali women have surfaced and shared by the TMC in the past few days.

In the first such videotape that emerged on May 4, Kayal was heard saying that the “staged” protests were lodged at the behest of Leader of the Opposition, Suvendu Adhikari, who was behind the “whole conspiracy”.

The second video was about women, who had earlier filed rape complaints, claiming that they were made to sign a blank paper by the BJP leaders and coerced to go to the police station.

In another clip, BJP candidate from Basirhat constituency and Sandeshkhali protestor Rekha Patra claimed that she “doesn’t know the rape survivors who were taken to Delhi to meet the President.” The TMC has already moved the Election Commission against National Commission for Women chairperson Rekha Sharma accusing her that she had misused her official position by allegedly telling some of the women in Sandeshkhali to lodge rape complaints against TMC leaders in the area.

“The TMC is using fake videos to change the narrative ahead of the polls. The TMC has the least regard for NCW or the dignity of the women of Sandeshkhali. All the videos released are fake and doctored,” BJP state spokesperson Samik Bhattacharya said.

The riverine Sandeshkhali area — situated on the borders of the Sundarbans, about 100 kilometres from Kolkata — had been on the boil in February with protests over allegations of sexual abuse and land grab against now arrested TMC leader Shajahan Sheikh and his supporters.

Bengal teachers’ recruitment ‘scam’: TMC MLA Manik Bhattacharya withdraws plea from Supreme Court

Bhattacharya, a former chairperson of the West Bengal Board of Primary Education, was arrested by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) on October 11 last year after night-long questioning
 Manik Bhattacharya, TT, 

PTI, New Delhi, 11.05.24 : Jailed TMC MLA Manik Bhattacharya has withdrawn from the Supreme Court his bail plea in a case related to alleged irregularities in the recruitment of primary school teachers in West Bengal.

A bench comprising justices Bela M Trivedi and Pankaj Mithal allowed Bhattacharya to file a fresh plea with some additional documents before the High Court.

ADVERTISEMENT
“The High Court may consider the petition as filed by the petitioner on merits and as expeditiously as possible. High Court may consider the matter afresh and in accordance with the law,” the bench said.

Bhattacharya, a former chairperson of the West Bengal Board of Primary Education, was arrested by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) on October 11 last year after night-long questioning.

The ED alleged the Palashipara MLA was not cooperating with the investigation.

On December 15, 2023, the top court had issued a notice to the ED on Bhattacharya’s appeal against a November 16 Calcutta High Court order rejecting his bail application.

The top court had on February 16 granted bail to Bhattacharya’s son Souvik in a money laundering case related to the case.

Remove unauthorised political party offices: HC

MP, 10 May 2024, Kolkata: The Calcutta High Court on Friday directed for the demolition of three unauthorised political party offices which were built on the West Bengal Housing Infrastructure Development Corporation (HIDCO) property. 

Following Justice Amrita Sinha’s order, a joint inspection was conducted by HIDCO and New Town Kolkata Development Authority (NKDA) wherein they identified the unauthorised structures. HIDCO filed a report mentioning that the area where the construction had taken place was owned by it. It was further placed before the court that the authorities were unaware of the setup. 
The advocate for the petitioner submitted that there were other similar constructions in the area as well. It was submitted that 35 such constructions, all party offices, were made within the HIDCO area. 
“Why don’t the authorities open a public redressal forum, wherein the public will give information on the unauthorised construction?” Justice Sinha questioned, adding: “You cannot protect your own property? Occupying the sidewalk? Built without any authorisation? 
Don’t you have any specific law?” According to a news agency, the three party offices were constructed by members of Trinamool Congress (TMC). On Friday, it was reported that most of these offices were locked and the banners were removed. Notice by HIDCO was found at the premises. 
Since the authorities have come to a conclusive finding that no permission was granted for raising the construction, Justice Sinha directed authorities not to allow the constructions to be used by any person for any purpose. 
The police were also directed to keep a strict vigil to ensure the same. The authorities were further directed to take steps for removal/demolition of the unauthorised construction at the earliest. 
 https://www.millenniumpost.in/bengal/remove-unauthorised-political-party-offices-hc-563317

Raj Bhavan’s woman employee to write to Prez seeking justice

Agencies, 10 May 2024, Kolkata: A day after Governor C V Ananda Bose screened multiple CCTV footage from Raj Bhavan, in a bid to clear the air over allegations of molestation brought against him by a contractual woman employee of the Governor’s House, the victim on Friday said she will seek President Droupadi Murmu’s intervention into the matter. 

The employee raised her objections to the public screening of unedited footage where her identity was allegedly disclosed since her face wasn’t blurred. Stating that she could not repose much hope on the Kolkata Police whose hands are tied on account of the constitutional immunity the Governor enjoys, the victim said she was going through severe depression and felt that writing to the President was the only recourse to justice. 
“I know that because of Constitutional immunity nothing will happen to a sitting Governor. But what about the offence he committed? I have decided to write to the President seeking her intervention in the matter. I am writing to her to get justice and nothing else,” the alleged victim told a news agency. 
Asked if she planned to seek Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s assistance regarding the incident, the woman recounted how the alleged incident occurred on the day the PM was scheduled to stay at Raj Bhavan. 
“While I was in distress and protesting, PM’s security personnel witnessed my anguish. Although I believe they informed Modi, I received no response from him. Writing to him now seems futile,” she remarked. 
The alleged victim, who holds a Masters in Computer Application (MCA), said she was contemplating seeking therapy to overcome the depression she has endured since lodging her complaint against Bose. 
“I’ve been suffering from severe depression and humiliation. Coming from a modest background, I never imagined facing such a situation. It’s been a nightmare for me and my elderly parents. I am considering meeting a psychologist for counselling to cope with this ordeal,” she said. 
Expressing her outrage over the screening of the footage without protecting her identity, the victim said she would also approach the police for redress. 
She considered the act of screening of the May 2 CCTV footage an “insult” and accused the Governor of further violating her privacy and confidentiality while lamenting the “lack of cooperation from the Governor” throughout the investigation process. “How did the Governor screen my footage without my permission? 
He committed a new crime today,” she said.

https://www.millenniumpost.in/bengal/bdeshi-held-for-travelling-without-valid-documents-563408?infinitescroll=1

Police gets hold of Raj Bhavan CCTV footage

MP, 10 May 2024, Kolkata: A day after the Raj Bhavan publicly disclosed selected CCTV footages, Kolkata Police is learnt to have finally got hold of the footages it had asked for as part of its probe into allegations of sexual harassment against the Governor C V Ananda Bose. Sources said the police have acquired the footage from the state’s Public Works department which is in charge of the security of Raj Bhavan. 

The footage was acquired on Thursday night. The police is now scanning through these since parts of the footage is said to be in congruence with the statements of the complainant, including the timings mentioned by the complainant. Earlier, the police had asked for the footage from Raj Bhavan authorities but was allegedly refused. 
The Governor had strictly asked the Raj Bhavan staff to refrain from giving any statements to the police. Police sources said that they are not probing any specific individual but certain complaints. 
As part of its ‘SACH KE SAAMNE’ (facing the truth) programme, Raj Bhavan disclosed CCTV footage to persons who either mailed or contacted the address provided by the Governor. 
Raj Bhavan released the hour-and-19-minute CCTV footage from May 2, the day when the woman contractual worker alleged she was sexually harassed by the Governor. 
The footage included recordings from two cameras in front of the North Gate from May 2. Footage from the two CCTVs showed the complainant approaching the Raj Bhavan’s officer-in-charge’s (OC) room from front and rear angles. 
Even though the complainant had alleged that the Governor sexually harassed her in the conference room on May 2, no footage from the inside of the Raj Bhavan was shown on Thursday. 
Neither was the Governor seen in any of the footage screened on Thursday. However, the complainant has now raised questions as to how the footages showing her were revealed when she has already lodged a complaint of sexual harassment. 
She is learnt to have alleged that the Governor had committed a crime against her and by disclosing the footage showing her, the Governor has committed another crime. She said that as far as she is aware, in such cases the identity of the victim cannot be disclosed without their permission. 
https://www.millenniumpost.in/bengal/police-gets-hold-of-raj-bhavan-cctv-footage-563326?infinitescroll=1

Bengal Guv must explain why he should not resign amid molestation allegations: Mamata

MP, 11 May 2024 4:24 PM West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Saturday slammed Governor C V Ananda Bose over allegations of molestation against him, and said he must explain why he should not step down. 

Addressing a poll rally here in support of TMC’s Hooghly candidate Rachana Banerjee, the CM also asserted she would not step inside the Raj Bhavan till Bose remains the governor. 
“The governor says ‘didigiri’ (high-handedness) will not be tolerated…But, I say Mr Governor, your ‘dadagiri’ will not work anymore,” the TMC supremo said. 
“Bose must explain why he should not resign after such allegations were levelled against him,” she said. A contractual woman employee of the Raj Bhavan had last week lodged a complaint with the Kolkata Police, alleging that she was molested by Bose in the governor’s house on April 24 and May 2. 
Bose had screened multiple CCTV footage of the Raj Bhavan on May 9, in a bid to clear the air over allegations of molestation brought against him. 
“The governor had released an edited video. I saw the entire footage and its contents are shocking. I have got another video… Your conduct is shameful,” the chief minister said. “I am not going to the Raj Bhavan till he is the governor… I prefer to meet him on the streets,” she asserted. 
https://www.millenniumpost.in/big-stories/bengal-guv-must-explain-why-he-should-not-resign-amid-molestation-allegations-mamata-563367?infinitescroll=1

Bangladeshi held for travelling without valid documents

Srishti Lakhotia, MP, 12 May 2024, Kolkata: A Bangladeshi national was apprehended from Sealdah-Duronto Express on May 8 after she was unable to produce a passport or a valid Indian visa. 

The Government Railway Police (GRP) at Sealdah registered a case against her under Section 370 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) which deals with trafficking of persons. The woman identified as Runa Begum, aged around 30 years, arrived in India on May 7. 
She claimed to the Railway Protection Force (RPF) Sealdah who apprehended her, that she came to India on directions of a friend named Sonia, whom she met on a social media platform. She further claimed that Sonia had promised her a job in New Delhi. 
She allegedly came to India through different means of transportation and was accompanied from Ranaghat to Sealdah by an unidentified person. She reached Sealdah via local train at around 2:30 pm and boarded the Express train from platform number 11. 
According to the information revealed by her to the RPF personnel, the unidentified person dropped her and left the station. Begum was allegedly in a state of distress when the RPF personnel found her in one of the coaches of Duronto Express. 
On further enquiry about her legal travel documents, Begum was unable to produce a passport on a valid Indian visa. 
According to the information shared by Eastern Railway, during the search of her luggage, a smartphone along with some Bangladeshi currency was found. Begum and the seized items were handed over to GRP for further legal proceedings. 
https://www.millenniumpost.in/bengal/bdeshi-held-for-travelling-without-valid-documents-563408?infinitescroll=1

SC sets Kejriwal free for 21 days, barshim from attending office, signing files

 The apex court asked the Delhi CM to not sign any official file unless absolutely necessary to obtain the LG’s sanction during the 21-day interim bail period. 

PTI, 10 May 2024, New Delhi : Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal cannot visit his office or the Delhi Secretariat during the tenure of his interim bail, the Supreme said on Friday as it imposed a slew of restrictions on him as part of the bail conditions.


It asked Kejriwal to not sign any official file unless absolutely necessary to obtain the Lieutenant Governor’s sanction during the 21-day interim bail period.

Imposing a raft of bail conditions on the embattled AAP leader, a bench of Justices Sanjiv Khanna and Dipankar Datta said, “He shall not visit the Office of the Chief Minister and the Delhi Secretariat.” “He shall be bound by the statement made on his behalf that he shall not sign official files unless it is required and necessary for obtaining clearance/ approval of the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi,” the top court said.

The bench also directed Kejriwal to furnish bail bonds in the sum of Rs 50,000 with one surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of the jail superintendent.

“He will not make any comment with regard to his role in the present case; and will not interact with any of the witnesses and/or have access to any official files connected with the case,” the top court said.

The apex court, while granting Kejriwal the relief said there was no doubt about the fact that serious accusations have been made against him but he has not been convicted yet.

“He does not have any criminal antecedents. He is not a threat to the society,” the bench said.

In a major relief to Kejriwal, the top court granted him interim bail till June 1 to campaign in the ongoing Lok Sabha elections.

The apex court said Kejriwal will have to surrender and go back to jail on June 2.

The matter relates to alleged corruption and money laundering in the formulation and execution of the Delhi government’s now scrapped excise policy for 2021-22. 

Molestation allegations: Governor footage leaves ‘room’ for doubt

 Footage was shown from two cameras — one near the North Gate and the other near the Raj Bhavan police outpost — not far from the main building 
The screening of the CCTV footage at Raj Bhavan. Sourced by the Telegraph.

Monalisa Chaudhuri, TT, Calcutta, 10.05.24 :  The Raj Bhavan showed CCTV footage for over an hour to a gathering of citizens on Thursday but not of the rooms where governor C.V. Ananda Bose has been accused of harassing a woman employee on April 24 and May 2.

The footage clearly showed the woman on the Raj Bhavan compound. On Thursday evening, she said: “Videos of mine have been circulated by Dr Bose without my permission and without blurring my face and body. I have learned that this is a crime.”

ADVERTISEMENT
She added: “I have already received this unblurred video from one of those who attended the event. That means it has been circulated and with the specific purpose of maligning my dignity.”

Indian law restricts people from revealing the identity of a sexual harassment complainant.

Bose had announced an email ID and a telephone number for ordinary citizens to register to see the footage. The Telegraph was at the Raj Bhavan to see the footage.

Footage was shown from two cameras — one near the North Gate and the other near the Raj Bhavan police outpost — not far from the main building.

A Raj Bhavan staff member said there was no CCTV camera in the first-floor room where the alleged May 2 incident happened. It could not be ascertained whether the room where the alleged April 24 incident took place has a CCTV camera.

Here’s what the footage showed and what it did not:

What was shown

· May 2, 5.33pm: A woman (purportedly the complainant) is seen walking hurriedly towards the police outpost. Her face is visible in the footage. She lifts her hand once, apparently asking something from a policeman nearby. She then walks towards the outpost.

Several men in white police uniform are seen standing, talking among themselves. A man and a second woman, wearing white and green salwar-kameez with a green dupatta, are seen walking behind the woman. The man and this second woman part ways as the man walks out of the main gate. The second woman comes near the outpost and stands there for a few minutes.

· 5.37pm: The second woman, later identified as a Raj Bhavan staff member, is seen loitering outside the police outpost and the sentry posts, making phone calls. The complainant has named this second woman to the police as one of those who allegedly tried to stop her when she was going to the police.

· 6.03pm: A fire tender arrives and heads into the Raj Bhavan as part of the security detail before the arrival of the Prime Minister. Narendra Modi visited Calcutta the same day and spent the night at the Raj Bhavan.

The complainant is still inside the police outpost.

· 6.29pm: The deputy commissioner (reserve force) of city police, who is in charge of Raj Bhavan security, is seen briefing police personnel. The complainant is still inside the police outpost and is not visible in the footage any more.

· 6.41pm: The footage ends with a large number of police personnel standing in the compound. The woman is still inside.

Not shown

· Any footage from inside the Raj Bhavan building where the alleged harassment happened. The closest that is visible in the footage is a portion of the Raj Bhavan compound several metres from the main building.

· Any footage from the room where, according to the woman’s police complaint, the governor had made physical advances on her on April 24.

· Any footage from the room where the governor had called her on May 2 and later allegedly tried to touch her inappropriately.

· Any footage from the room where the woman was allegedly confined and where her phone and bag were allegedly snatched.

· Any footage from the ground-floor corridor from where she says she entered the office of a senior Raj Bhavan official to report the incident before she came out of the building.

The woman has told the police she was crying while walking down the corridor. “There is a camera in the corridor and one near the lift. The footage from any of these cameras would have shown me crying,” the woman told this newspaper on Thursday.

· Footage of the woman stepping out of the outpost. (The woman has alleged that some Raj Bhavan staff were waiting outside the outpost and tried to send her home in an official vehicle, which she refused.)

Teacher held for using forged documents to obtain loan

Gourab Neto, MP, 9 May 2024, Kolkata: A primary school teacher was arrested on Wednesday afternoon by the cops of Bidhannagar Cyber Crime Police Station for allegedly obtaining a personal loan using forged documents. 

The woman identified as Payel Mondal was produced at the Bidhannagar ACJM Court on Thursday and has been remanded to police custody for five days. According to sources, during the middle of last year, Mondal, a school teacher at a primary school of Kashipur in South 24-Parganas had appealed for a personal loan of Rs 3 lakh through an agency from a private bank. 
After a few days, the loan was sanctioned and the amount was disbursed to Mondal’s State Bank of India (SBI) account. Sources informed that after obtaining the loan, the private bank noticed that the Easy Monthly Instalment (EMI) was not paid for a few months. 
While scrutinising the documents, the private bank authorities found that Mondal had used the PAN Card and Aadhar Card of another woman whose name is the same but the photo was different. Immediately a complaint was lodged at the Bidhannagar Cyber Crime police station against Mondal. 
During the probe, cops gathered evidence and finally on Wednesday she was arrested from her residence in Kasba. Police are further probing to find out who else is connected with this fraud and if any organised gang is active to cheat the banks.

https://www.millenniumpost.in/bengal/teacher-held-for-using-forged-documents-to-obtain-loan-563174

Guv Bose shows CCTV footage of Raj Bhavan to common people

IANS, Kolkata, May 9, 2024 : Amid allegations of molestation against West Bengal Governor C.V. Ananda Bose, the Governor’s House on Thursday showed 69-minute CCTV footage of the Raj Bhavan premises dated May 2 to around 100 ‘common people’.


On May 2, a temporary female staff at the Raj Bhavan filed a police complaint accusing the Governor of ‘outraging her modesty’, triggering a political storm in the state.

Denying the charge vehemently from the beginning, the Governor on Wednesday announced that the CCTV footage of the Raj Bhavan will be screened at the Governor’s House for the common people, barring Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and members of the police force, on Thursday.

In the CCTV footage screened in three parts, the Governor could not be seen in any frame.

The footage from May 2 showed recordings of two CCTV cameras installed in the North Gate of the Raj Bhavan from 5.32 p,m. to 6.41 p.m. The screening event was titled ‘Sach Ka Samna’.

Although the Governor was not spotted in the footage, the complainant was seen twice — once entering the police post inside the Raj Bhavan premises, and then coming out of it and entering an adjacent room.

Heavy deployment of police was seen in the footage on account of the arrival of Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the Raj Bhavan on the night of May 2.

Since the announcement of the screening on Wednesday, the Governor’s office received hundreds of applications from the common people seeking to attend the event.

The CCTV cameras inside the Governor’s House are maintained by the Public Works Department, while the monitoring is done by the Kolkata Police.

New videos surface, claim women deceived to lodge complaints of rape; TMC slams BJP

PTI, 09 May, 2024 : The Trinamool Congress on Thursday accused the BJP of spreading falsehood about the incidents of Sandeshkhali, after several purported videos claimed that a local female BJP leader made multiple women sign on blank papers, which were later filled up as complaints of sexual assault against TMC leaders.


The allegation was levelled within three days after the TMC took to social media to unveil a Sandeshkhali “sting operation” video featuring a local BJP leader Gangadhar Koyal who claimed that the rape allegations were “staged” and were lodged at the behest of state Leader of Opposition, Suvendu Adhikari.

In a bid to reassert its claims, the TMC shared a fresh set of videos on Thursday of purported women residents of Sandeshkhali who alleged they were “manipulated” by the BJP into filing “false rape cases”.

The party also shared a fresh video where BJP’s Basirhat candidate and one of the leading faces of Sandeshkhali protests, Rekha Patra, was seen questioning the identity of the contingent of “Sandeshkhali victims” who were earlier taken to Delhi by the state BJP leaders to meet President Draupadi Murmu and relate their ordeal.

On Wednesday, the TMC had alleged that BJP leaders were issuing death threats to women who have expressed their willingness to withdraw their complaints of rape.

PTI, however, could not independently verify the authenticity of any of the tapes released so far.

Referring to the newly released videos, state minister and senior TMC leader, Shashi Panja, condemned the BJP for “perpetuating a false narrative on Sandeshkhali sexual assaults” and threatening victims who sought to retract their police complaints.

“Sandeshkhali victims may have had a few complaints over land grab. But they never had complaints of sexual offence. This again proves that the BJP is spreading falsehood. This despicable act of fabrication and intimidation will not go unpunished,” Panja said.

West Bengal’s Leader of Opposition Suvendu Adhikari, on the other hand, dismissed TMC’s claims, alleging that the videos were fabricated by ‘bhaipo’ (nephew), an oblique reference to TMC leader Abhishek Banerjee and the party’s private poll-cum-political consultant, I-PAC, who “distributed money” to get the job done.

“We are soon moving court against both and will ensure they are taken to task for spreading such malicious lies,” Adhikari said while participating in a nomination filing rally of Rekha Patra at Basirhat.

BJP Rajya Sabha MP and party spokesperson Samik Bhattacharya told reporters that the more such videos surface, the higher the margin of votes by BJP from Sandeshkhali assembly segment under Basirhat Lok Sabha seat.

He said the state administration itself prepared a list of those whose plots of land had been taken away by TMC leader Shahjahan Sheikh, who was arrested and later suspended by the party, and started the process of returning those.

So circulating one video after another now contradicts the state’s move to set right the wrongs committed by the ruling party, he said.

Bhattacharya said the BJP Sandeshkhali mondal president, whose name figured in the purported video, requested the CBI to include the clipping in its probe.

Leader of Opposition Adhikari claimed that people could see through the web of Trinamool’s deceit and Patra would gain a lead of 1.5 lakh votes from the Sandeshkhali region itself.

In one of the latest videos, a woman was heard saying, “We were deceived into signing on blank papers. We discovered later that rape complaints had been lodged in our names. This is a blatant lie.” The woman said the authorities should take action against the woman BJP leader who manipulated them to sign blank papers.

Another alleged Sandeshkhali resident echoed similar sentiments in a separate video, claiming that they have become victims of a scheme orchestrated by BJP leader Piyali Das.

According to information last received, Das has been summoned by the local police for questioning.

In the video which features Patra, the BJP candidate was heard seconding another woman standing next to her who alleged that the victims who were taken to meet the President were arbitrarily chosen by local BJP leaders.

“Several oppressed women were taken to meet the President. We weren’t part of that group. We had gone to meet the Prime Minister (in Barasat where he addressed a public meeting on March 6). If not us, then who were these so-called oppressed women who met the President?” she asked.

“We have a right to know that if we were in Sandeskhali at that time, then who became our faces to meet the President?” Patra was heard adding.

Regarding this, Bhattacharya said hundreds of women had levelled charges of atrocities against TMC leaders from different islands of the area.

“It is clear that Patra did not know every one of them and this purported video must have been recorded before she was fielded as a candidate from Basirhat,” he said.

The TMC, meanwhile, has moved the Election Commission urging the poll body to initiate criminal proceedings against the BJP leaders concerned, including Adhikari, for “orchestrating the conspiracy including paying bribes to the women of Sandeshkhali to falsely raise complaints and attempting to influence central investigating agencies and other constitutional authorities”.

CPI(M) Basirhat Lok Sabha candidate Nirapada Sardar claimed that both TMC and BJP are trying to confuse the people of Sandeshkhali by circulating such videos. 

ED to file chargesheet against Kejriwal, Kavitha

 Enforcement Directorate plans to file a charge sheet in the Delhi excise policy-linked money laundering case, naming Arvind Kejriwal, BRS leader K Kavitha, and others as accused, including individuals and companies.

PTI, May 09, 2024: The Enforcement Directorate (ED) is expected to soon file a fresh charge sheet in the Delhi excise policy-linked money laundering case and it may name Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal, BRS leader K Kavitha and some others as accused, official sources said on Thursday. The federal agency had arrested Kejriwal from his official residence here on March 21 under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) while Kavitha, the MLC daughter of former Telangana chief minister K Chandrashekar Rao, was taken into custody from Hyderabad on March 15.

Official sources said a prosecution complaint against half-a-dozen entities, including the two politicians, some linked individuals and companies, has been readied and the agency may file it before a special PMLA court here within the next 4-5 days.

The accused will be charged with money laundering and the prosecution complaint will be filed under sections 45 and 44(1) of the PMLA, the sources said.

The agency may also name the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) in this charge sheet along with attachment of some fresh assets in the case that was registered in 2022.

SC reserves orders on state’s challenge to CBI probing cases

The stand taken by the Central government today was the reiteration of the position stated by it in the course of its submissions on 3 May and earlier in its affidavit in response to West Bengal government’s petition.

Parmod Kumar | SNS  |  New Delhi | May 9, 2024 : he Supreme Court on Wednesday reserved its judgment on the West Bengal government’s plea challenging the Central Bureau of Investigation undertaking investigation into the cases in the state without its statutorily mandated prior consent, as state government asserted that such a situation would be in derogation of the federal nature of Centre-State relationship under Indian constitution.

Reserving the judgment, a Bench of Justice B R Gavai and Justice Sandeep Mehta gave both – the petitioner West Bengal government and the central government time till Friday, 17 May, to file note of their respective submissions not more than 20 to 25 pages each. Giving time till 17 May to file written submissions, the Bench said that they would be writing the judgment during a seven week-long summer vacation of the top court starting from 20 May.

While the West Bengal government asserted that the Central Bureau of Investigation cannot register cases and undertake any investigation in the State without its prior nod, after it has already withdrawn its general consent since 16 November, 2018, the central government reiterated that the central investigating agency was an independent of its control and was not functioning under its control and supervision.

By its 16 November decision, the West Bengal government has withdrawn its general consent permitting the CBI to undertake any investigation in the state.

The Solicitor General, Tushar Mehta appearing for the central government said that its (central government) presence in the CBI was limited to the transfer, posting, territorial jurisdiction – areas it can investigate – and the finances of the agency including emoluments. As far as registration of cases and their investigation was concerned, the agency was an autonomous and independent entity.

On a poser from the Bench as to under which ministry the CBI comes, the Solicitor General Mehta said that it could be the department of personnel & training (DoPT) or the ministry of home affairs. However, the Solicitor General said that the government cannot ask the CBI to register cases.

The stand taken by the Central government today was the reiteration of the position stated by it in the course of its submissions on 3 May and earlier in its affidavit in response to West Bengal government’s petition.

However, an attempt by the Solicitor General Mehta drawing a parallel between the independence enjoyed by the CBI with that of the independence of the judiciary was not accepted by the Court. The bench said any comparison of independence of CBI with that of judiciary is an “incorrect analogy”.

Appearing for the West Bengal government, senior advocate Kapil Sibal told the Bench that after the state government withdrew its general consent to the CBI to probe cases in the state, the central agency could not have undertaken any investigation in the State without prior consent of the state government.

“The West Bengal government had withdrawn the consent on 16 November, 2018. The cases registered by the CBI, which are under the challenge, after the withdrawal of the consent” could not be investigated, Sibal told the Bench pointing out that, “The constitutional question is whether after the withdrawal of the consent, can you (central government) allow your agency to enters my State, without my consent.”

He further argued that when in parliament a question is asked about the CBI, it is the DoPT under the Prime Minister that answers the questions.

Assailing the Centre’s stand that CBI can register cases on its own, Sibal said, “That is the most dangerous proposition that the Centre has advanced before the court, which will be destructive of the federal nature of the Centre-State relationship.”

Sibal cited the instance of “CBI registering a case in a state without its prior nod and the same is challenged and by the time the matter is decided it would take 4 to 5 years and by then the trial in the case would be over.”

The West Bengal government in its suit has challenged the registration of cases by the CBI without its consent. It has referred to the provisions of the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act 1946, stating that the CBI is mandated under the statute to take the State government’s consent before registering cases.